Independent Guide to Britain's Budget and Discount Stores
Budget Stores Plain-English guides to Britain's discount shops

Home / Budget Store Comparisons

Budget Store Comparisons

Budget stores look alike from the pavement. Low prices, wide ranges, busy aisles. Step inside, and the differences appear quickly. One is built around fashion, another around homeware, a third around health and beauty, and a fourth around branded labels at reduced prices. This guide sets out those differences, so you can choose the store that fits the shop you actually want to do.

The Verdict

No single budget store suits every shop. The right choice depends on what you are buying, whether you want to shop in store or online, and how much browsing you are happy to do.

Good for

Shoppers who match the store to the shop, fashion to Primark, homeware to The Range, health and beauty to Home Bargains.

Anyone who reads a comparison before travelling, so the visit fits the range.

Watch out for

A store that is strong in one range may be thin in another, so a single visit may not cover everything.

Online service varies widely, and a store that is strong in store may be weak online.

Why budget stores are hard to compare

Budget stores are hard to compare because they are not the same kind of shop. Primark is a fashion retailer, The Range is a homeware and garden retailer, Home Bargains is a general discounter with a health and beauty strength, and TK Maxx is an off-price retailer selling branded labels at reduced prices.

The way to compare them is to start with the shop, not the store. A shopper buying clothing will find Primark and TK Maxx the natural pair. A shopper buying homeware will find The Range and B and M the natural pair. A shopper buying everyday items will find Home Bargains and Poundland the natural pair.

The most compared pair: B and M against Home Bargains

B and M against Home Bargains is the most compared pair among budget stores, and the reason is that both are large general discounters. Both sell a wide range of everyday items, both keep prices low, and both trade mainly through large branches. A shopper choosing between them is choosing between two stores that look alike on the surface, and the differences are in the details of the range.

B and M has garden centres and a food range including frozen food, which Home Bargains does not match in the same way. Home Bargains is stronger on health and beauty and on own label lines, which B and M does not match in the same way either. The full B and M against Home Bargains comparison sets out those differences in detail, with a table and a look at the upsides and downsides of one of the two stores.

Fashion against off-price fashion

Primark against TK Maxx is the fashion comparison, and it is a comparison of two different models. Primark sells own brand clothing at low prices, with a wide range that follows the seasons. TK Maxx sells branded and designer labels at reduced prices, with stock that changes constantly and sizes that vary.

A shopper who wants a particular item in a particular size will usually find Primark the easier shop, because the range is built to be restocked. A shopper who enjoys browsing and is happy to take what is there will usually find TK Maxx the more rewarding shop, because the stock is always changing. The full Primark against TK Maxx comparison sets out the two models side by side.

The pound shop pair, and the homeware pair

Poundland against Poundstretcher is the pound shop pair, and it is a comparison of two retailers built around low price points. Both sell everyday items at low prices, and both trade mainly through branches. The differences are in the range and the format, with Poundstretcher carrying a wider general range and Poundland holding to a simpler low price model. The full Poundland against Poundstretcher comparison explains how they differ.

The Range against B and M is the homeware pair, and it is a comparison of a homeware and garden specialist against a general discounter with garden centres. The Range is deeper in homeware and garden, and B and M is wider across general, garden and food. A shopper buying furniture or garden items will find The Range the deeper shop, and a shopper buying across several ranges in one trip will find B and M the wider one. The full The Range against B and M comparison sets out the balance.

Wilko, The Range, Savers and Poundland

Wilko against The Range is a comparison with a twist, because Wilko now sits inside The Range as a brand. The two share an online approach, and both issue discount codes from time to time, but they carry different ranges and different histories. Wilko is the old high street name for home and garden, and The Range is the larger homeware and garden retailer that now houses it. The full Wilko against The Range comparison explains how the two sit together.

Savers against Poundland is the health and beauty comparison, and it is a comparison of a specialist against a generalist. Savers is built around health and beauty, with own label lines beside branded lines. Poundland is built around general everyday items at low prices. A shopper buying health and beauty will find Savers the deeper shop, and a shopper buying across many ranges will find Poundland the wider one. The full Savers against Poundland comparison sets out the difference.

Online service, compared

Online service is one of the clearest differences between budget stores. The Range, Wilko, TK Maxx and Home Bargains run a full online store with delivery, and each of them offers tracking through its own channels. Primark offers click and collect and does not deliver to your home. Poundland, B and M and Savers are mainly store based, with limited or no online delivery.

Compare the store to the shop, not the store to the store. The right budget store is the one that sells what you want, in the way you want to buy it.

That split matters more than it first appears. A shopper who wants an order delivered should start with one of the four that deliver, and a shopper who wants a Primark item should plan for collection. A shopper who wants an item from a mainly store based retailer should plan a visit to a branch. The online shopping guide sets out each retailer online service in full.

Prices, and how they are set

Prices at budget stores are set in different ways, and that shapes the comparison. Primark, Poundland, Home Bargains and B and M set low shelf prices as their main offer, and the price you see is the price you pay. TK Maxx sets a reduced ticket price beside an original price, and the gap between them is the discount.

That difference in pricing is why a single price comparison rarely settles the question. A low shelf price, a reduced ticket price, and a code applied at checkout are three different ways of reaching a low total, and the right comparison is the total for the items you want, through the channel you will use.

How to use a comparison

The way to use a comparison is to start with your own shop. List what you want to buy, and how you want to buy it, in store or online, delivered or collected. Then read the comparison for the pair that sells those items, and look for the differences that touch your shop.

It also helps to remember that a comparison is a summary of differences, not a recommendation to shop at one store. Each store has strengths, and each has limits, and the balance between them depends on the shop.